The Role of Inferred Harm to Others in Perceptions of Price (Un)Fairness
نویسندگان
چکیده
Thirty years ago, psychologist Daniel Kahneman and economists Jack Knetsch, and Richard Thaler (1986a & b) proposed that fairness matters in the marketplace. They presented evidence-based community rules of fairness that are encapsulated in the “principle of dual entitlement”; consumers are entitled to the reference transaction (e.g., price) and, similarly, the firm is entitled to its reference profit. Their findings suggest that it is perceived as unfair for a firm to “exploit an increase in its market power” to charge a higher price than the reference, but that it is fair for a firm to charge a higher price in order to maintain its profit, and additionally, that there is an asymmetry such that it is also fair for a firm to maintain a price that leads to increased profit due to decreased costs (KKT 1986a&b). This research generated an interesting literature on perceptions of price fairness such that today we have established that perceptions of unfairness matter, i.e., they impact important marketplace outcomes (e.g., Campbell, etc.) and have also identified a variety of factors that influence perceptions to price fairness. The majority of the research in this literature has focused on understanding factors that influence the extent to which consumers perceive an appropriate reference to have been violated. Research examines what references consumers use, focusing on the price setter (e.g., costs), time (e.g., temporal proximity), and other consumers. Research that examines the role of other consumers proposes and demonstrates that higher prices paid relative to other consumers, often called relative disadvantage, will typically be perceived as unfair (Haws and Beardon 2006; Feinberg et al., 2003, etc.) and may even have a larger impact on perceptions of unfairness than other factors, such as the price setter’s costs (Haws and Beardon 2006; Xia and Monroe 2004). However, much of the research since KKT (1986a&b) has focused on perceptions of fairness made by a consumer who has been charged a specific price. However, consumers often evaluate the fairness of prices charged to other consumers, as well as those charged to themselves. We extend the existing literature by proposing that an additional factor that influences consumers’ perceptions of price fairness is the extent to which a given price or price change is inferred to negatively impact consumers beyond the focal consumer him or herself. More generally, we propose that questions of harm, both to consumers and to firms, are important to consumers’ perceptions of marketplace fairness. There are five important contributions of this research. First, we provide evidence that inferences of harm to consumers is an important influence on perceptions of price unfairness; importantly, we show that a maintained price can be perceived as unfair. Second, this means that consumer vulnerability and product necessity are important to understanding price unfairness. Third, we show that the influence of harm to consumers on PPF is balanced by the influence of harm to the price setter; consumers’ perceptions of unfairness are a result of a balance between the impact on consumers and on the firm. Fourth, the role of inferred harm to consumers in PPF creates conditions under which relative disadvantage (i.e., being charged a higher price than other consumers) is perceived to be fair, counter to most existing research on comparison to other consumers. Fifth, the role of inferred harm creates conditions under which a price decrease can be perceived as unfair.
منابع مشابه
How Inferences of Harm to Other Consumers Influence Perceptions of Price (Un)Fairness
Thirty years ago, psychologist Daniel Kahneman and economists Jack Knetsch, and Richard Thaler (1986a & b) showed that fairness matters in the marketplace. They presented evidence-based community rules of fairness that are encapsulated in the “principle of dual entitlement”; consumers are entitled to the reference transaction (e.g., price) and, similarly, the firm is entitled to its reference p...
متن کاملExamining the Role of Price Fairness in Sport Consumer Ticket Purchase Decisions
Ticket pricing in professional sports is transitioning from a cost-based to demand-based approach. It has been argued that consumer perceptions of fairness regarding demand-based ticket pricing could influence purchase decisions. Perceptions of unfair pricing practices can lead to dissatisfaction and negatively affect purchase behavior. However, familiarity with demand-based pricing strategies ...
متن کاملRelationship between Professional Ethics and Organizational Commitment
Background: In recent years, professional ethics has effect on the activity, individual and group performance and organizational results. The aim of this study was to investigate the relationship between professional ethics and organizational commitment. Methods: The research method is applied in terms of purpose and descriptive-correlational research. The statistical population includes 50 em...
متن کاملThe Role of Employee Whistleblowing and Raising Concerns in an Organizational Learning Culture – Elusive and Laudable?; Comment on “Cultures of Silence and Cultures of Voice: The Role of Whistleblowing in Healthcare Organisations”
It is inevitable that healthcare workers throughout their careers will witness actual or potential threats to patient safety in the course of their work. Some of these threats will result in serious harm occurring to others, whilst at other times such threats will result in minimal harm, or a ‘near miss’ where harm is avoided at the last minute. Despite organizations encouraging employees to ‘s...
متن کاملMoral Chivalry
Moral perceptions of harm and fairness are instrumental in guiding how an individual navigates moral challenges. Classic research documents that the gender of a target can affect how people deploy these perceptions of harm and fairness. Across multiple studies, we explore the effect of an individual's moral orientations (their considerations of harm and justice) and a target's gender on altruis...
متن کامل